Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
00000176-e6f7-dce8-adff-f6f770410000PublicSource is an independent, nonprofit news group that focuses on original investigative reporting about critical issues facing Pittsburgh and the Western Pennsylvania region. It was launched to undertake in-depth reporting in the public interest.PublicSource is a content partner of 90.5 WESA.More about PublicSource here.

When Officials Threaten Demolition, These People Step In To Preserve Pittsburgh's Historic Homes

*Part two in a three-part series.

Through the dated kitchen and a hallway with a gaping hole, past the stacks of dusty Bibles and art history books, a grand staircase snakes through the old mansion. Cracked vases are strewn at the foot of the landing — at one time, the homeowner was a collector.

Now, this home on Millionaire’s Row in McKeesport smells of mildew and you can’t stay inside for too long without getting lightheaded. But the crown molding still wraps the perimeter of each bedroom. You can imagine its Victorian glory through the rubble.

“Every house has a story,” says Maryann Huk, director of the McKeesport Preservation Society [MPS].

And every house has its own remnants of life. Sometimes dishes are left on the table. Food in the refrigerator. And the owners long gone. It’s like an image taken straight from the aftermath of the Great Depression, Huk says.

In Allegheny County, there’s roughly a dozen preservation groups, and most are nonprofits, according to Preservation Pittsburgh.


Credit Connor Mulvaney / PublicSource
It'd likely be cheaper to demolish this Victorian mansion than to complete a historical preservation, but then it'd be adding to more than 2,500 vacant lots already in McKeesport.

MPS, one of those nonprofits, plays a vital role in McKeesport where more than a quarter of homes in its school district are tax delinquent. Some buildings are on the brink of collapse, and the city is threatening demolition.

The McKeesport Housing Authority is currently planning to demolish the former First Baptist Church at 409 Olive St. As the last brownstone structure in the area, it has enough historical significance for MPS to speak out against the housing authority’s move.

In a recent Facebook post, the preservation society said the housing authority's quest to demolish the church for a greenspace project is ironic for a town with more than 2,500 vacant lots.

"We're building huggers."

  The office of McKeesport Mayor Michael Cherepko did not comment for this story. After three phone calls and an email, his office did not provide a representative to discuss demolition projects.

“We’re just trying to ensure that properties that don’t need to come down, don’t come down,” Huk said. Otherwise, that’s money poorly spent. Huk’s goal is to get as many houses as possible back on the tax roll, and with their character still intact.

Generally, most demolitions cost between $5,000 and $10,000, according to Mark Masterson, executive director of the Northside Community Development Fund.

Historical preservations in McKeesport run between $15,000 and $25,000 on average, said Mike Pachulski, another preservation expert in McKeesport.

Huk's latest renovation project, a Victorian home built in 1900, has been a target for demolition because it has been vandalized. She wishes the city would reconsider demolishing abandoned homes when residents agree to take them on as fixer-upper projects. That way, homes like her 1900 Victorian may be rented or sold, rather than lost.

“We’re building huggers,” she said.

Pachulski said he thinks most vacant houses can be rehabbed.

“If the foundation is intact, and there isn’t severe structural damage, it’s just a matter of how much time and money someone is willing to spend fixing it,” he said.

"Every house has a story."

If her 1900 Victorian can be sold, Huk hopes to include an agreement in the deed to keep the home’s identity.

When a home is not eligible for the National Register of Historic Places, an easement or covenant can be written into the deed of the house to ensure that certain aspects of the home cannot be removed and certain additions may not be made.

That way, the new owner knows the house is supposed to be preserved, not torn down or even reconfigured.

“This is one way we can make sure the homes we work on don’t become empty lots,” Huk said.

“Historically-sensitive” solutions

In Pittsburgh, the Northside Community Development Fund is doing similar work on a much larger scale.

Rather than tear down homes that have been slated as blighted, vacant or tax-delinquent, the group tries to find uses that take advantage of what’s already standing.

At one point, Masterson, the fund’s executive director, said its parent organization — the Northside Leadership Conference [NSLC] — could have been considered the biggest developer of single-family housing in the city.

The organization’s job is to find funding for community groups to develop homes and commercial properties in neighborhoods where blight is hurting the real estate market.

“The city has got away from financing neighborhood groups to do that type of development,” Masterson said. “You can’t take 60 years of population decline and undo that with a couple of big projects.”

The group finds funding and loans it out to community groups who wish to develop homes and commercial properties in North Side neighborhoods. Loans from the Urban Redevelopment Authority and local banks, as well as grants and deferred mortgages, provide funds for this development.

Masterson said the North Side has experienced a long history of neglect by the city. This led individual neighborhood groups to take on real estate development.

The challenge, though, is that properties are worth little to start and the costs are high. According to Masterson, total development costs for most projects average $215,000 per unit, with an average construction cost of about $135,000.

"It was the first time the community flexed their muscle to say, 'We don't want this crap.'"

But people have a tremendous pride in place. Masterson has been witnessing it since he first became a community organizer in the 1980s.

Back then, a local doctor named Dr. GeorgeMagovern wanted to try his hand at development. He bought a vacant Giant Eagle supermarket near the NorthsideChronicle’s offices with an intention of building a Burger King, Masterson said.

More than 300 community members came together to block Magovern’s plans. They wanted to prevent him from tearing down homes on several central streets for his project.

“It was the first time the community flexed their muscle to say, ‘We don’t want this crap,’” Masterson said.

In the early 2000s, Masterson’s group funded a project on the same site. The block of homes on the corner of Middle and Tripoli streets now stand in proud North Side fashion, complete with red brick and bright green and gold doors.

In Allegheny West, the organization redeveloped a series of 4,000-square-foot homes. They didn't have enough money to renovate both the inside and outside of the homes, so the group focused on fixing roofs, windows and porches. The group sold the homes for between $40,000 and $50,000, giving homeowners an incentive to buy them and finish rehabbing the inside.

Private developers’s default is often to demolish and rebuild. In the North Side, Masterson and his organization have a long history of rescuing buildings that could be targets.

“People said we should tear them down,” he said. “But if we did, we’d lose something that we can’t replace.”

Find this report and others on the site of our partner, PublicSource