Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Group Urging State Courts To Discipline Justices More Strictly, Transparently

Keith Srakocic
Former state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin, left, leaves court with her husband Greg Melvin after she and her sister, Janine Orie, were sentenced for their February convictions on corruption in Orie Melvin's election campaign, on May 7, 2013.

Over the last several years, three separate scandals involving three separate judges have hit the commonwealth’s Supreme Court.

These and other issues have prompted nonpartisan group Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts to release a report detailing the judicial discipline system’s shortfalls—and what the state can do to fix it.

The high-profile problems came one after another.

In 2013, Justice Joan Orie Melvin was found guilty of multiple felonies related to her use of state employees for campaign work.  

In 2014, Justice Seamus McCaffery was implicated in the now-infamous Porngate scandal, for sending thousands of lewd emails from a work account. He was suspended, and ultimately resigned.

Around the same time, Justice Michael Eakin, was also implicated in the email debacle. The court first exonerated him, but after more of his emails leaked, he was suspended and resigned last year.

President and CEO of the PMC group, Maida Milone, said there’s a common problem in all these cases—the way the court handles discipline.

“There were not only weaknesses in the characters of the justices who were involved, but weaknesses in the judicial discipline system itself,” she said. “If the system they operate in doesn’t require accountability, transparency, and fairness, transgressions are going to occur.”

Among other things, PMC is advocating more openness in selection of the Judicial Conduct Board, a disclosure process to prevent conflicts of interest, and additional powers that would let the board pursue charges against judges even after they’ve resigned.

Most of these fixes could be made with rules changes, should the court system take the recommendations to heart. Though Milone notes, some would probably take legislative action.

The court system has so far not responded to the recommendations.