After 2 Years, Trump Tax Cuts Have Failed To Deliver On GOP's Promises

Dec 20, 2019
Originally published on December 21, 2019 3:05 am

Two years ago Friday, Republicans in Congress passed a sweeping tax cut. It was supposed to be a gift-wrapped present to taxpayers and the economy. But in hindsight, it looks more like a costly lump of coal.

Passed on a party-line vote, the tax cut is the signature legislative accomplishment of President Trump's first term. He had campaigned hard for the measure, promising it would boost paychecks for working people.

"Our focus is on helping the folks who work in the mailrooms and the machine shops of America," he told supporters in the fall of 2017. "The plumbers, the carpenters, the cops, the teachers, the truck drivers, the pipe-fitters, the people that like me best."

In fact, more than 60% of the tax savings went to people in the top 20% of the income ladder, according to the nonpartisan Tax Policy Center. The measure also slashed the corporate tax rate by 40%.

"It will be rocket fuel for our economy," Trump promised.

Boosters of the tax cut insisted the economy would grow so fast, it would more than make up for the revenue lost to lower rates.

"The tax plan will pay for itself with economic growth," Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin said.

It hasn't worked out that way.

"It was unbelievable at the time, and it's proven to be absolutely untrue," said Maya MacGuineas, president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. "The tax cuts were never going to — and have not — come anywhere close to paying for themselves."

Corporate tax revenues fell 31% in the first year after the cut was passed. Overall tax revenues have declined as a share of the economy in each of the two years since the tax cut took effect.

Don't see the graphic above? Click here.

"Not surprising, if you cut taxes, you get less in revenues," MacGuineas said. "And what we've been doing at the same time is we've been increasing spending. And no surprise, our deficit has exploded."

The federal deficit this year was $984 billion — an extraordinary figure at a time when the country is not mired in recession or widespread war.

The tax cut also failed to produce a permanent boost in economic growth, despite promises from Republican supporters.

"After eight straight years of slow growth and underperformance, America is ready to take off," Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said when the tax cut passed two years ago.

In fact, the economy grew 2.9% last year — exactly the same as in 2015.

The tax cut, along with increased government spending, did give a short-term lift to the economy and businesses temporarily boosted investment. But the rocket fuel burned off quickly. Business investment declined in the last two quarters.

"There was an acceleration in terms of momentum for business investment, but it was rather short-lived," said Gregory Daco of Oxford Economics. "A year further down the road, we're really not seeing much of any leftover of this fiscal stimulus package."

Hampered in part by the president's trade war, the economy is projected to grow only about 2% this coming year. That's below the administration's target of 3% and slightly below the average growth rate since 2010.

To be sure, the stock market is booming, and unemployment is near record lows. But while most Americans give the economy high marks, that doesn't extend to the tax cut. A Gallup Poll last tax season found only about 40% of Americans approved of the cut while 49% disapproved.

Even though experts say most workers did get a bump in their take-home pay, it was largely invisible to many taxpayers. Only about 14% of those surveyed by Gallup believe their taxes went down. (That figure includes 22% of Republicans, 12% of Democrats and 10% of independents.)

"For millions of middle-class Americans, it is not a very happy anniversary," said Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore.

Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, said while wealthy Americans are celebrating their tax savings from the past two years, working people feel like an afterthought.

Perhaps it's an acknowledgement of that sentiment that the president is now talking about another round of tax cuts, after the 2020 election. "We're going to be doing a major middle-income tax cut, if we take back the House," Trump promised in November.

The president made similar promises before last year's midterm election. But the follow-up to his 2017 tax cut never materialized.

Copyright 2020 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

Two years ago today, Republicans in Congress passed a sweeping tax cut. It was supposed to be a gift-wrapped present for taxpayers and the economy, but in hindsight, it looks more like a budget-busting lump of coal. A Gallup poll this year showed that more than four out of 10 Americans aren't even sure if the tax cut saved them money. NPR's Scott Horsley reports.

SCOTT HORSLEY, BYLINE: The tax cut passed on a party line vote two years ago is these signature legislative accomplishment of President Trump's first term. Trump campaigned hard for the measure, telling supporters a vote to cut taxes is a vote to put America first.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP: Our focus is on helping the folks who work in the mailrooms and the machine shops of America - the plumbers, the carpenters, the cops, the teachers, the truck drivers, the pipefitters, the people that like me best.

HORSLEY: In fact, more than 60% of the tax savings went to people in the top 20% of the income ladder. Corporations also won big. Their tax rate was slashed by 40%.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

TRUMP: And it will be rocket fuel for our economy.

HORSLEY: Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin insisted the economy would grow so fast after the tax cut, it would more than make up for the revenue lost to lower rates.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

STEVEN MNUCHIN: The tax plan will pay for itself with economic growth.

HORSLEY: It hasn't worked out that way.

MAYA MACGUINEAS: It was unbelievable at the time, and it's proven to be absolutely untrue. The tax cuts were never going to, and have not, come anywhere close to paying for themselves.

HORSLEY: Maya Macguineas of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget notes that tax revenues as a share of the economy fell in each of the two years since the tax cut took effect.

MACGUINEAS: Not surprising - if you cut taxes, you get less than revenue. And what we've been doing at the same time is we've been increasing spending, and - no surprise - our deficit has exploded.

HORSLEY: The deficit this year was nearly a trillion dollars, a level of red ink usually seen only when the government's fighting a recession or a widespread war. But at least the economy got a permanent boost from the tax cut, right? Here's what Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell promised when the cut was passed.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

MITCH MCCONNELL: After eight straight years of slow growth and underperformance, America is ready to take off.

HORSLEY: In fact, GDP growth last year was exactly the same as in 2015. Gregory Daco of Oxford Economics says the tax cut did provide a short-term boost to the economy, but the rocket fuel burned off quickly.

GREGORY DACO: There was an acceleration in terms of momentum for business investment, but it was rather short-lived. And a year further down the road, we're really not seeing much of any leftover of this fiscal stimulus package.

HORSLEY: To be sure, the stock market is booming, and unemployment is at near-record lows. But the tax cut has not delivered the sustained bounce in economic growth that was promised. Hamstrung in part by the president's trade war, the economy is projected to grow only about 2% this coming year, slightly below the average growth rate since 2010. While most Americans give the economy high marks, that doesn't extend to the tax cut. A Gallup poll last tax season found just 40% of Americans approve of the cut, while 49% disapprove. Democratic Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon says the cut has become a political liability for the GOP.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

RON WYDEN: The people who are celebrating are the high-fliers, corporate executives. But if you work for a living, this sure looks like a con job.

HORSLEY: Now, most workers did enjoy some tax savings from the cut, but since it was spread throughout the year, that increase in take-home pay was invisible to many people. Just 14% of those surveyed by Gallup believe their taxes went down. Perhaps it's an acknowledgement of that sentiment that the president is now talking about another round of tax cuts after the 2020 election, a kind of make-up for some of those same workers in mailrooms and machine shops.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

TRUMP: We're going to be doing a major middle-income tax cut if we take back the House.

HORSLEY: Trump made similar promises before last year's midterm election, but that follow-up to his 2017 tax cut never materialized.

Scott Horsley, NPR News, Washington. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

Tags: