Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
Keystone Crossroads: Rust or Revival? explores the urgent challenges pressing upon Pennsylvania's cities. Four public media newsrooms are collaborating to report in depth on the root causes of our state's urban crisis -- and on possible solutions. Keystone Crossroads offers reports on radio, web, social media, television and newspapers, and through public events.Our partner stations are WHYY in Philadelphia, WPSU in State College and witf in Harrisburg. Read all of the partner stories here.Pittsburgh’s WQED joins the collaboration as an associate partner. Support for this project comes from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.

PA Towns Fear Financial Devastation After Top Court Decision Cutting Casino Tax Revenue

Lindsay Lazarski


Last month, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court dealt a bad hand to communities that host casinos.

Municipalities including Chester City, Bensalem Township and Erie County stand to lose millions in revenue after part of the state's gambling code was declared unconstitutional on Wednesday.

Mount Airy, LLC, a small casino in Mount Pocono, sued the state Department of Revenue, arguing that the gambling code's "local share assessment" provision unfairly burdened some casinos.

Under state law, casinos had to pay out 2 percent or $10 million of annual slot revenue — whichever was larger — to the municipalities where they're located. (That money is sometimes sliced up between more than one township or shared between contiguous communities.)

In effect, small casinos had to pay out $10 million, even if that greatly exceeded 2 percent of their slot revenue, thus taxing different casinos at different rates and violating the Pennsylvania Constitution's uniformity clause, the plaintiffs argued.

A majority of state Supreme Court justices agreed.

"It's shocking and devastating," said Bensalem Mayor Joe DiGirolamo. Ten million dollars amounts to just over 20 percent of the township's annual budget, and it was a major selling point for welcoming the casino, according to DiGirolamo.

He said the only place to cut significant costs from Bensalem's budget would be in public safety, and "that's not an option."

Chester City, in Delaware County, stands to lose an even larger percentage of its budget, according to chief financial officer Nafis Nichols.

"Twenty-five percent of our (City of Chester) yearly revenue is predicated on the monies we receive from Harrah's Philadelphia," he said in a statement. "If the current decision is upheld, it would be devastating for Chester."

Chester, already on a state watch list for cities with chronic financial problems, is unable to break even with the local share assessment contributing to its bottom line.

More examples from around the state:

  • Erie divides its money somewhat differently between county and townships;  all told, it stands to lose about $11 million, spread among different communities, reports
  • Bethlehem stands to lose $8.8 million, or 12 percent of its budget, and Allentown $3.5 million, according to the Morning Call.

SugarHouse Casino in Philadelphia and small "boutique" casinos, including one in Valley Forge, are governed by a different tax standard and exempt from the ruling.
Four months to fix it

The justices baked some language into their decision to soften the blow to cities, such as a 120-day stay on implementing the decision.

"We are mindful that our decision may significantly affect many counties and municipalities that have ordered their affairs in reliance upon [local share assessments]," read the majority opinion.

Lawmakers are already exploring legal options for rewriting the gambling code to square it with the state Constitution.

"I guarantee you, we will be on this very, very quickly and have something when we go back in October and try to correct this as quickly as possible," said state Rep. Gene DiGirolamo of Bensalem.

Lawyers for Mount Airy casino are also working hard — to push for a refund.

Tom Leonard, counsel for Mount Airy, said he is exploring options to recoup some of the millions paid out before the tax was struck down. The Supreme Court decision includes language barring that possibility.

"You can't just say you made a mistake and then keep the money," he said. Though pragmatic for cities, the stay is also on tenuous legal ground, according to Leonard.

If the casino does appeal parts of the court decision to the federal level, "we would fight that as hard as we could," said  Gene DiGirolamo.

To make informed decisions, the public must receive unbiased truth.

As Southwestern Pennsylvania’s only independent public radio news and information station, we give voice to provocative ideas that foster a vibrant, informed, diverse and caring community.

WESA is primarily funded by listener contributions. Your financial support comes with no strings attached. It is free from commercial or political influence…that’s what makes WESA a free vital community resource. Your support funds important local journalism by WESA and NPR national reporters.

You give what you can, and you get news you can trust.
Please give now to continue providing fact-based journalism — a monthly gift of just $5 or $10 makes a big difference.